Well okay, here goes nothing.. I've had this idea in my head for a few
weeks which won't go away, and it's time to tell the world :)
First of all, let me just say here that I love the JRSC.. There are a lot of turbo, nos, and n/a fanatics around, and that's great.. But I love the JRSC in particular for a few important reasons: 1) It adds a significant amount of ass-kicking power. 2) It's (supposed to be) cheaper than a turbo. 3) It's (supposed to be) easier to install than a turbo. 4) It's (supposed to be) more reliable than a turbo system 5) It preserves the Indy-like torque curve of the Honda motor. Overall it's been a hell of a lot of fun to drive. However despite these advantages, I have discovered in my recent but brief JRSC experiences that the system does have some serious drawbacks.. For the purposes of this discourse, I'll divide the main problems into two categories: Timing Control and Fuel Control. I think that the JR BTC, MSD BTM, and J&S Ultraguard have pretty much taken care of the timing control. But Fuel Control is another story altogether. It seems that the typical scenario goes like this:
So by the time all this is done, I've invested $1335.00 in fuel management which should have been taken care of from the beginning. This is a bad solution. So of course now everyone will say, "Just get a Hondata" but that thing is insanely overpriced too. By the time you're done paying for the Hondata unit itself, plus the stupid software, plus the OBD-I ECU and $250 wiring harness, plus dyno time, you've spent almost as much $$ as what the supercharger itself cost. That may be the ideal solution from a bottomless-pocket standpoint, but it just doesn't sit well with me.. I think we should be able to get the JRSC Honda system running reliably and well-tuned without dropping another several grand. This stuff doesn't have to be expensive. A creative mind and an eye for bargains can get you far. When I was in college I designed a digital dash display for a friend with a tricked out 87 Chevy Cavalier. I'm not joking - the thing looked like a space shuttle cockpit. Two flourescent backlit LCD graphic displays, with digital & analog speedo, fuel level, odometer, trip meter, digital voltage meter, temperature display. Plus a Race display which detected "racing mode" (when you hammered it), graphed speed vs time, and displayed calculated 0-60 time and 1/4 mile time and speed. No shit - check it out under hardware @ www.fascinationsoftware.com. How much would you expect to pay for this? It cost him $250 for _ALL_ the electronics - embedded computer, displays, all of it. He spent another $700 on a stainless steel plate and fabrication work. But the point is - this stuff doesn't have to be so expensive, and we can put some of ourselves into the work. Of course now you probably see where I'm going with this train of thought.. I'd like us to make our own special JRSC honda all-purpose fuel controller.. I'm calling it the Open Import Fuel Tuner, for reasons which will become apparent shortly.. Here are my design constraints:
With a system like this a person could could use the stock fuel pump and regulators, and only upgrade the injectors to achieve complete fuel control and tunability while forgetting about the $2k Hondata or other solutions. I'm intending to GPL the code so that anyone who wants will be ablke to tweak it and add more features. I'll also be posting _all_ the schematics and documentation on my website so that anyone may make their own for the cost of the parts. I'm not planning on interfacing a display or keypad for the first version of the device, for two reasons: 1) an small LCD display sucks for tuning purposes - you can't get enough information from it. and 2) You shouldn't be tuning while driving anyway. There will be a high-speed serial port for laptop hookup, and a badass Win32 app for tuning the car.. And of course the source code for that program will also be GPL'd and available on my website.. By foregoing the display/keypad, I think I'll be able to keep the cost of the parts very close to the price of a JR MAP controller alone. The electrical hook-up for a system like this would be pretty simple. I envision it like this: IAT ___/---------\_____ ECU IAT O2 ___|---------| TPS ___|---OIFT--|_____ ECU TPS TDC ___|---BOX---| IGN ___|---------| MAP ___\---------/_____ ECU MAP So I'm pumped.. It seems to me that if we get together we can create a tuning computer that is: 1) extremely cheap, 2) almost infinitely extensible by anyone who can learn 68HC16 assembly language (piece of cake :) ), and 3) exactly suited to our engine control needs. I believe that this controller could solve all of our fuel delivery problems and allow us to achieve excellent tunabiliy with only the added cost of the parts for the controller and big injectors. Here's what I'm envisioning for the major software features of the first version:
Of course for those of us who don't have the desire or time to build up an electronic device, there is a good possibility that I will find a way to offer pre-built units for sale. Wouldn't this thing be cool? I probably never would have built this thing alone, but one of my best friends (who is a mad DSM tuner) has really started going gung-ho on this idea, and it's developing some momentum. He's already told several of his DSM comrades, and apparently there has been a strong response. I just got eight different 68hc16 manuals from UPS today - several thousand pages for a grand total of $0.00 (Damn I love Motorola). We'll be making a version for DSMs that interfaces with a Karman sensor instead of the MAP. Since this is going to be a completely open project, anyone with a little EE/comsci experience could port the project to work on a totally different car. But this will be a very time-consuming and long project if I have to do everything myself. I'm completely open to anyone who would like to donate their time and/or expertise. I need help mainly from these areas:
It will be a long-term project, since I have a full-time job. Probably 9 months at least before it could be released to the general tuner public. But if you feel like you could donate something to an effort like this, and would like to, please email me.. If anyone has any thoughts on why this would/would not be a good project, speak up! Richard |